Skip to main content

Table 11 Finn agreement test for FinG 1 with and without visualization tool

From: Investigating factors that affect the human perception on god class detection: an analysis based on a family of four controlled experiments

Program

Visualization

#class

#part

Finn

p-value

Agreement level

Monopoly

Without

4

6

0.567

0.0135

Moderate

 

With

2

5

0.4

0.221

-

 

From without visualization to with visualization evolution

 

-

Tetris

Without

4

6

0.567

0.0135

Moderate

 

With

6

5

0.467

0.0307

Moderate

 

From without visualization to with visualization evolution

 

SAME

Tic Tac Toe

Without

4

6

0.567

0.0135

Moderate

 

With

2

5

0.6

0.0788

-

 

From without visualization to with visualization evolution

 

-

Chess

Without

6

5

0.467

0.0307

Moderate

 

With

6

6

0.6

0.0014

Moderate

 

From without visualization to with visualization evolution

 

SAME

Jackut

Without

6

4

0.5

0.0403

Moderate

 

With

6

6

0.667

0.000226

Substantial

 

From without visualization to with visualization evolution

 

INCR

Solitaire

Without

4

5

0.4

0.113

-

 

With

8

6

0.617

0.000147

Substantial

 

From without visualization to with visualization evolution

 

-