Skip to main content

Table 8 Overall agreement (OA) of pairs of the tools

From: On the evaluation of code smells and detection tools

 

inf-jde

inf-jsp

inf-pmd

jde-jsp

jde-pmd

pmd-jsp

MobileMedia

GC

Avg

75.12%

97.94%

98.79%

74.36%

74.36%

99.15%

Median

73.33%

97.83%

100%

73.33%

73.33%

100%

Std Dev

3.684

1.682

1.269

3.729

3.508

1.572

Min

70.27%

96%

96%

67.57%

67.57%

96.15%

Max

82%

100%

100%

82%

80%

100%

GM

Avg

94.29%

99.25%

99.66%

93.70%

93.94%

99.24%

Median

94.09%

99.01%

99.64%

93.10%

93.43%

99.01%

Std Dev

1.863

0.615

0.327

1.488

1.706

0.618

Min

91.94%

98.33%

99.01%

91.94%

91.94%

98.52%

Max

97.07%

100%

100%

95.93%

96.65%

100%

FE

Avg

95.52%

96.79%

n/a

93.12%

n/a

n/a

Median

97.04%

97.53%

n/a

92.59%

n/a

n/a

Std Dev

3.127

1.370

n/a

1.635

n/a

n/a

Min

91.13%

94.88%

n/a

91.67%

n/a

n/a

Max

99.51%

98.58%

n/a

97.04%

n/a

n/a

Health Watcher

GC

Avg

89.75%

97.90%

96.59%

87.82%

88.10%

96.76%

Median

89.80%

97.90%

96.74%

87.76%

88.78%

96.76%

Std Dev

0.914

0.289

0.425

1.483

1.880

0.397

Min

88.31%

97.40%

95.76%

85.71%

84.42%

96.10%

Max

91.30%

98.31%

97.09%

90.68%

89.83%

97.46%

GM

Avg

89.92%

99.49%

99.77%

90.44%

90.15%

99.60%

Median

90.06%

99.52%

99.84%

90.66%

90.26%

99.68%

Std Dev

1.185

0.096

0.108

1.138

1.110

0.130

Min

87.39%

99.29%

99.56%

88.05%

87.83%

99.34%

Max

92.06%

99.58%

99.86%

92.48%

92.20%

99.72%

FE

Avg

97.78%

97.27%

n/a

97.12%

n/a

n/a

Median

98.17%

97.51%

n/a

97.45%

n/a

n/a

Std Dev

0.915

0.676

n/a

0.980

n/a

n/a

Min

95.98%

95.98%

n/a

95.27%

n/a

n/a

Max

98.44%

97.98%

n/a

98.16%

n/a

n/a