Skip to main content

Table 8 Overall agreement (OA) of pairs of the tools

From: On the evaluation of code smells and detection tools

  inf-jde inf-jsp inf-pmd jde-jsp jde-pmd pmd-jsp
MobileMedia GC Avg 75.12% 97.94% 98.79% 74.36% 74.36% 99.15%
Median 73.33% 97.83% 100% 73.33% 73.33% 100%
Std Dev 3.684 1.682 1.269 3.729 3.508 1.572
Min 70.27% 96% 96% 67.57% 67.57% 96.15%
Max 82% 100% 100% 82% 80% 100%
GM Avg 94.29% 99.25% 99.66% 93.70% 93.94% 99.24%
Median 94.09% 99.01% 99.64% 93.10% 93.43% 99.01%
Std Dev 1.863 0.615 0.327 1.488 1.706 0.618
Min 91.94% 98.33% 99.01% 91.94% 91.94% 98.52%
Max 97.07% 100% 100% 95.93% 96.65% 100%
FE Avg 95.52% 96.79% n/a 93.12% n/a n/a
Median 97.04% 97.53% n/a 92.59% n/a n/a
Std Dev 3.127 1.370 n/a 1.635 n/a n/a
Min 91.13% 94.88% n/a 91.67% n/a n/a
Max 99.51% 98.58% n/a 97.04% n/a n/a
Health Watcher GC Avg 89.75% 97.90% 96.59% 87.82% 88.10% 96.76%
Median 89.80% 97.90% 96.74% 87.76% 88.78% 96.76%
Std Dev 0.914 0.289 0.425 1.483 1.880 0.397
Min 88.31% 97.40% 95.76% 85.71% 84.42% 96.10%
Max 91.30% 98.31% 97.09% 90.68% 89.83% 97.46%
GM Avg 89.92% 99.49% 99.77% 90.44% 90.15% 99.60%
Median 90.06% 99.52% 99.84% 90.66% 90.26% 99.68%
Std Dev 1.185 0.096 0.108 1.138 1.110 0.130
Min 87.39% 99.29% 99.56% 88.05% 87.83% 99.34%
Max 92.06% 99.58% 99.86% 92.48% 92.20% 99.72%
FE Avg 97.78% 97.27% n/a 97.12% n/a n/a
Median 98.17% 97.51% n/a 97.45% n/a n/a
Std Dev 0.915 0.676 n/a 0.980 n/a n/a
Min 95.98% 95.98% n/a 95.27% n/a n/a
Max 98.44% 97.98% n/a 98.16% n/a n/a